Ridout Road rentals: Difference between revisions

From PoliticalSG
VisualWikitext
(Created page with " The '''Ridout Road rental investigation''' was an inquiry conducted in Singapore in 2023 into the leases of state-owned bungalows by two senior ministers, '''K. Shanmugam''' and '''Vivian Balakrishnan''', members of the '''People's Action Party (PAP)'''. The properties, located at 26 and 31 Ridout Road, were rented following processes managed by the '''Singapore Land Authority (SLA)''', which oversees government-owned properties. The investigation, launched by the ''...")
 
Line 4: Line 4:
The properties, located at 26 and 31 Ridout Road, were rented following processes managed by the '''Singapore Land Authority (SLA)''', which oversees government-owned properties.
The properties, located at 26 and 31 Ridout Road, were rented following processes managed by the '''Singapore Land Authority (SLA)''', which oversees government-owned properties.


The investigation, launched by the '''Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB)''' under the direction of Prime Minister '''Lee Hsien Loong''', aimed to determine if there was any abuse of power or conflict of interest. An independent review, led by Senior Minister '''Teo Chee Hean''', was also conducted. Both the CPIB and Teo concluded that there was no evidence of wrongdoing or undue benefit.
The investigation, launched by the '''Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB)''' under the direction of Prime Minister '''Lee Hsien Loong''', aimed to determine if there was any abuse of power or conflict of interest.  
 
An independent review, led by Senior Minister '''Teo Chee Hean''', was also conducted. Both the CPIB and Teo concluded that there was no evidence of wrongdoing or undue benefit.
----
----


=== Background ===
=== Background ===
Ridout Road is part of the affluent '''Bukit Timah''' area and is designated by the '''Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA)''' as a "Good Class Bungalow Area," one of Singapore's most exclusive residential zones. The bungalows at 26 and 31 Ridout Road had been vacant for extended periods before being rented by Shanmugam and Balakrishnan, respectively.
Ridout Road is part of the affluent '''Bukit Timah''' area and is designated by the '''Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA)''' as a "Good Class Bungalow Area," one of Singapore's most exclusive residential zones.  
 
The bungalows at 26 and 31 Ridout Road had been vacant for extended periods before being rented by Shanmugam and Balakrishnan, respectively.
[[File:Ridout location.png|thumb|Locations of No. 26 and No. 31 Ridout Road]]


=== Allegations and Initial Responses ===
=== Allegations and Initial Responses ===
On '''6 May 2023''', '''Kenneth Jeyaretnam''', secretary-general of the '''Reform Party''', published a blog post questioning how the ministers could afford the high rents associated with the Ridout Road properties. He also called for greater transparency in the SLA's leasing process, particularly given that Shanmugam oversaw the SLA as Minister for Law.
On '''6 May 2023''', '''Kenneth Jeyaretnam''', secretary-general of the '''Reform Party''', published a blog post <ref>https://kenjeyaretnam.com/2023/05/06/mrs-lhl-said-singapores-system-was-honest-in-that-there-were-no-hidden-perks-for-government-ministers-apart-of-course-from-her-secret-salary-so-can-anyone-shed-any-light-on-what-rents-shanmugam/</ref>questioning how the ministers could afford the high rents associated with the Ridout Road properties.  
 
He also called for greater transparency in the SLA's leasing process, particularly given that Shanmugam oversaw the SLA as Minister for Law.


The SLA issued a statement on '''12 May 2023''', affirming that the rental of both properties adhered to established procedures.  
The SLA issued a statement<ref>https://www.sla.gov.sg/articles/highlights/2023/response-to-media-queries-regarding-kenneth-jeyaretnam-s-social-media-posts-on-the-rental-of-no-26-and-31-ridout-road</ref> on '''12 May 2023''', affirming that the rental of both properties adhered to established procedures.  


Jeyaretnam also raised concerns about alleged links between the transactions and '''Livspace''', an interior design firm led by Shanmugam’s son. Both Livspace and Shanmugam strongly denied these claims, labelling them baseless and defamatory.
Jeyaretnam also raised concerns about alleged links between the transactions and '''Livspace''', an interior design firm led by Shanmugam’s son.  


==== Investigation Initiation ====
Both Livspace and Shanmugam strongly denied these claims, labelling them baseless and defamatory.
 
=== Investigation Initiation ===
On '''23 May 2023''', Prime Minister Lee announced that he had requested reports from relevant agencies and tasked Senior Minister Teo Chee Hean with conducting an independent review. Additionally, the CPIB initiated an investigation to examine the allegations.
On '''23 May 2023''', Prime Minister Lee announced that he had requested reports from relevant agencies and tasked Senior Minister Teo Chee Hean with conducting an independent review. Additionally, the CPIB initiated an investigation to examine the allegations.


=== Investigation Findings ===
== Investigation Findings ==


==== Property Details ====
=== Property Details ===
The bungalows at 26 and 31 Ridout Road were state-owned properties managed by the SLA. Both had been vacant for several years before the ministers’ leases.
The bungalows at 26 and 31 Ridout Road were state-owned properties managed by the SLA. Both had been vacant for several years before the ministers’ leases.


* '''26 Ridout Road (Shanmugam):'''
==== '''26 Ridout Road (Shanmugam):''' ====
** Vacant since December 2013.
[[File:26 Ridout Road.png|thumb|Google Map capture of 26 Ridout Road in August 2021]]
** The property was rented in June 2018 for S$26,500 per month, with the lease renewed in 2021 at the same rate. The lease was renewed again in 2024, but the revised rental amount is unknown.
* Vacant since December 2013.
** Shanmugam paid over '''S$400,000''' for renovations, including '''S$61,400''' for a car porch.
* Prevailing Guide Rent is at S$26,500.
** The SLA incurred '''S$515,400''' for essential repairs. Concerns about overgrown land adjacent to the property led Shanmugam to offer to clear and maintain the area at his own cost, citing public health risks. The SLA assessed that the land could only be maintained if it was included in the tenancy, resulting in an increase of the property’s size to 23,164 square metres (249,340 sq ft).
* The property was rented in June 2018 for S$26,500 per month, with the lease renewed in 2021 at the same rate. The lease was renewed again in 2024, but the revised rental amount is unknown.
* The clearance cost of '''S$172,000''' was initially paid by the SLA but recovered through Shanmugam’s rent. Shanmugam also paid an additional '''S$25,000 annually''' to maintain the adjacent land.
* Shanmugam paid over '''S$400,000''' for renovations, including '''S$61,400''' for a car porch.
* '''31 Ridout Road (Balakrishnan):'''
* The SLA incurred '''S$515,400''' for essential repairs.
** Vacant since July 2013.
* Concerns about overgrown land adjacent to the property led Shanmugam to offer to clear and maintain the area at his own cost, citing public health risks. The SLA assessed that the land could only be maintained if it was included in the tenancy, resulting in an increase of the property’s size from 9,350 sqm to 23,164 square metres (249,340 sq ft).
** Rented in '''October 2019''' for '''S$19,000 per month''', revised to '''S$20,000''' in 2022 upon lease renewal.
 
** Balakrishnan spent over '''S$200,000''' on renovations.
* The clearance cost of '''S$172,000''' was initially paid by the SLA but recovered through Shanmugam’s rent. Shanmugam also allegedly said to borne the maintenance of the adjacent land at the cost of approximately '''S$25,000'''.
* [[File:Satellite 26 Ridout Road 2018.png|center|thumb|Satellite of 26 Ridout Road in 2018 before Shanmugam rented the place]]
[[File:Satellite 26 Ridout Road.png|center|thumb|Construction of a large swimming pool and car porch, as well as the cutting down of large swathes of trees. (Google Earth satellite in September 2019)]]
 
==== '''31 Ridout Road (Balakrishnan):''' ====
[[File:31 Ridout Road.png|thumb|Google Map capture of 31 Ridout Road in August 2024]]
* Vacant since July 2013.
* Two unsuccessful bids were made below the prevailing Guide Rent, i.e., $12,000 in July 2018 and $5,000 in August 2018.
* Prevailing Guide Rent, which was $18,800
* The SLA incurred '''S$570,500''' for essential repairs. 
* Rented in '''October 2019''' for '''S$19,000 per month''', revised to '''S$20,000''' in 2022 upon lease renewal.
* Balakrishnan spent over '''S$200,000''' on renovations.
 
=== CPIB and Independent Review ===
The CPIB report found "no evidence to suggest any abuse of position by the ministers for personal gain."


==== CPIB and Independent Review ====
The independent review by Teo concluded that:
The CPIB report found "no evidence to suggest any abuse of position by the ministers for personal gain." The independent review by Teo concluded that:


* Shanmugam’s identity as the prospective tenant of 26 Ridout Road was not disclosed to the SLA during negotiations.
* Shanmugam’s identity as the prospective tenant of 26 Ridout Road was not disclosed to the SLA during negotiations.
Line 44: Line 66:


== Timeline ==
== Timeline ==
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!Date
!Event
|-
|January 2017
|Minister Shanmugam asks for list of a few properties available to the public to rent. Minister Shanmugam visited some of these properties including No. 26 Ridout Road.
|-
|January 2018
|Minister Shanmugam appointed a property agent to represent him for the rental transaction of No.26 Ridout Road State property.
|-
|29 March 2018
|Chief Executive of Singapore Land Authority makes declaration to Permanent Secretary of MinLaw and reported that the processing of rental transaction was properly done with no conflict of interest.
|-
|June 2018
|Mrs Shanmugam signed a tenancy agreement for a 3+3+3-year term. The rental was set at S$26,500 for the property measuring 23,164 sqm (original size at 9,350 sqm).
|-
|11 September 2018
|Mrs Balakrishnan contacted SLA's Managing Agent and negotiated on rental price.
|-
|October 2019
|Mrs Balakrishnan signs tenancy agreement for 3+2+2 with SLA at a monthly rental of S$19,000 for the property at 31 Ridout Road measuring 9,157.36 sqm.
|-
|June 2021
|Lease extended at S$26,500 a month for the same property size.
|-
|October 2022
|Mrs Balakrishnan requested and obtained a renewal of another 3+2 instead of the original 2+2. Monthly rental is increased to S$20,000.
|-
|6 May 2023
|Kenneth Jeyaretnam published a blog post about the Ministers renting the Ridout Road properties.
|-
|12 May 2023
|SLA issues statement to confirm No. 26 and No. 31 Ridout Road were rented to Minister Shanmugam and Minister Balakrishnan.
|-
|17 May 2023
|Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong directed the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) to investigate.
|-
|22 May 2023
|PM Lee Hsien Loong instructed Senior Minister Teo Chee Hean to conduct a separate review  in order to address wider potential process or policy issues, which go beyond the scope of CPIB’s investigation.
|-
|28 June 2023
|Reports are accepted by PM Lee Hsien Loong and have them published.
|}


=== Parliamentary Debate ===
=== Parliamentary Debate ===

Revision as of 16:14, 18 November 2024

The Ridout Road rental investigation was an inquiry conducted in Singapore in 2023 into the leases of state-owned bungalows by two senior ministers, K. Shanmugam and Vivian Balakrishnan, members of the People's Action Party (PAP).

The properties, located at 26 and 31 Ridout Road, were rented following processes managed by the Singapore Land Authority (SLA), which oversees government-owned properties.

The investigation, launched by the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) under the direction of Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, aimed to determine if there was any abuse of power or conflict of interest.

An independent review, led by Senior Minister Teo Chee Hean, was also conducted. Both the CPIB and Teo concluded that there was no evidence of wrongdoing or undue benefit.

Background

Ridout Road is part of the affluent Bukit Timah area and is designated by the Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) as a "Good Class Bungalow Area," one of Singapore's most exclusive residential zones.

The bungalows at 26 and 31 Ridout Road had been vacant for extended periods before being rented by Shanmugam and Balakrishnan, respectively.

Locations of No. 26 and No. 31 Ridout Road

Allegations and Initial Responses

On 6 May 2023, Kenneth Jeyaretnam, secretary-general of the Reform Party, published a blog post [1]questioning how the ministers could afford the high rents associated with the Ridout Road properties.

He also called for greater transparency in the SLA's leasing process, particularly given that Shanmugam oversaw the SLA as Minister for Law.

The SLA issued a statement[2] on 12 May 2023, affirming that the rental of both properties adhered to established procedures.

Jeyaretnam also raised concerns about alleged links between the transactions and Livspace, an interior design firm led by Shanmugam’s son.

Both Livspace and Shanmugam strongly denied these claims, labelling them baseless and defamatory.

Investigation Initiation

On 23 May 2023, Prime Minister Lee announced that he had requested reports from relevant agencies and tasked Senior Minister Teo Chee Hean with conducting an independent review. Additionally, the CPIB initiated an investigation to examine the allegations.

Investigation Findings

Property Details

The bungalows at 26 and 31 Ridout Road were state-owned properties managed by the SLA. Both had been vacant for several years before the ministers’ leases.

26 Ridout Road (Shanmugam):

Google Map capture of 26 Ridout Road in August 2021
  • Vacant since December 2013.
  • Prevailing Guide Rent is at S$26,500.
  • The property was rented in June 2018 for S$26,500 per month, with the lease renewed in 2021 at the same rate. The lease was renewed again in 2024, but the revised rental amount is unknown.
  • Shanmugam paid over S$400,000 for renovations, including S$61,400 for a car porch.
  • The SLA incurred S$515,400 for essential repairs.
  • Concerns about overgrown land adjacent to the property led Shanmugam to offer to clear and maintain the area at his own cost, citing public health risks. The SLA assessed that the land could only be maintained if it was included in the tenancy, resulting in an increase of the property’s size from 9,350 sqm to 23,164 square metres (249,340 sq ft).
  • The clearance cost of S$172,000 was initially paid by the SLA but recovered through Shanmugam’s rent. Shanmugam also allegedly said to borne the maintenance of the adjacent land at the cost of approximately S$25,000.
  • Satellite of 26 Ridout Road in 2018 before Shanmugam rented the place
Construction of a large swimming pool and car porch, as well as the cutting down of large swathes of trees. (Google Earth satellite in September 2019)

31 Ridout Road (Balakrishnan):

Google Map capture of 31 Ridout Road in August 2024
  • Vacant since July 2013.
  • Two unsuccessful bids were made below the prevailing Guide Rent, i.e., $12,000 in July 2018 and $5,000 in August 2018.
  • Prevailing Guide Rent, which was $18,800
  • The SLA incurred S$570,500 for essential repairs.
  • Rented in October 2019 for S$19,000 per month, revised to S$20,000 in 2022 upon lease renewal.
  • Balakrishnan spent over S$200,000 on renovations.

CPIB and Independent Review

The CPIB report found "no evidence to suggest any abuse of position by the ministers for personal gain."

The independent review by Teo concluded that:

  • Shanmugam’s identity as the prospective tenant of 26 Ridout Road was not disclosed to the SLA during negotiations.
  • Balakrishnan’s rental amount was comparable to other properties of similar condition.
  • Both leases complied with SLA procedures, and there was no abuse of power or conflict of interest.

Timeline

Date Event
January 2017 Minister Shanmugam asks for list of a few properties available to the public to rent. Minister Shanmugam visited some of these properties including No. 26 Ridout Road.
January 2018 Minister Shanmugam appointed a property agent to represent him for the rental transaction of No.26 Ridout Road State property.
29 March 2018 Chief Executive of Singapore Land Authority makes declaration to Permanent Secretary of MinLaw and reported that the processing of rental transaction was properly done with no conflict of interest.
June 2018 Mrs Shanmugam signed a tenancy agreement for a 3+3+3-year term. The rental was set at S$26,500 for the property measuring 23,164 sqm (original size at 9,350 sqm).
11 September 2018 Mrs Balakrishnan contacted SLA's Managing Agent and negotiated on rental price.
October 2019 Mrs Balakrishnan signs tenancy agreement for 3+2+2 with SLA at a monthly rental of S$19,000 for the property at 31 Ridout Road measuring 9,157.36 sqm.
June 2021 Lease extended at S$26,500 a month for the same property size.
October 2022 Mrs Balakrishnan requested and obtained a renewal of another 3+2 instead of the original 2+2. Monthly rental is increased to S$20,000.
6 May 2023 Kenneth Jeyaretnam published a blog post about the Ministers renting the Ridout Road properties.
12 May 2023 SLA issues statement to confirm No. 26 and No. 31 Ridout Road were rented to Minister Shanmugam and Minister Balakrishnan.
17 May 2023 Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong directed the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) to investigate.
22 May 2023 PM Lee Hsien Loong instructed Senior Minister Teo Chee Hean to conduct a separate review in order to address wider potential process or policy issues, which go beyond the scope of CPIB’s investigation.
28 June 2023 Reports are accepted by PM Lee Hsien Loong and have them published.

Parliamentary Debate

On 3 July 2023, a parliamentary session was convened to debate the findings.

  • K. Shanmugam stated that his residents judged him by his commitment to public service rather than his income or residence.
  • Vivian Balakrishnan emphasised that he had been "scrupulously careful" to ensure transparency and compliance with procedures.
  • Leader of the Opposition Pritam Singh raised concerns about ministers requesting information for personal use, while MP Sylvia Lim questioned the propriety of the transactions.
  1. ↑ https://kenjeyaretnam.com/2023/05/06/mrs-lhl-said-singapores-system-was-honest-in-that-there-were-no-hidden-perks-for-government-ministers-apart-of-course-from-her-secret-salary-so-can-anyone-shed-any-light-on-what-rents-shanmugam/
  2. ↑ https://www.sla.gov.sg/articles/highlights/2023/response-to-media-queries-regarding-kenneth-jeyaretnam-s-social-media-posts-on-the-rental-of-no-26-and-31-ridout-road
Retrieved from "https://politicalsg.com/index.php?title=Ridout_Road_rentals&oldid=279"